08 and 12 Bonnes Mares from Pierre Naigeon

2012 Pierre Naigeon Bonnes Mares
Bright ruby. Red berries nose, very primary fruity, not too intense. Fresh aciditu, ripe tannins, easy going for Bonnes Mares, lacks concentration, again plain fruity. 88

2008 Pierre Naigeon Bonnes Mares
Bright ruby. Red berries, more nuanced, floral notes nose. Freshish acidity, ripe tannins, leaner palate, lacks a bit of substance, fresh, should be more complex, good length. 89