1980 Pommery Cuvée Spesiale Louise:
Pale amber, gold tint. Yeast, chalk, some coffee and orange
peel. Fresh acidity, elegant mousse, refreshing palate, elegant almost
flinty minerals. Long finish. 93
2008 Salwey Kirchberg GG Spätburgunder:
Bright
ruby. Some herbs behind slightly unripe strawberries, towards scented.
Fresh acidity, ripe tannins, light mid-palate, a little bit warm finish.
Mineraly and herbal finish. A bit edgy texture. Good length. 88
2008 Kistler Vine Hill Vineyard Russian River Valley Lemon yellow. Rich, buttery, minerals, apples and creamy feel to the nose. A whiff of popcorn and ripe lemons. Fresh acidity, creamy texture, minerals, almost smoky, ever so slightly warm touch, vanilla and extreem length. Visqous and seemless. Nailed producer. 93+
2006 Hervé Souhaut Sainte Epine
Deep
ruby. Cherries, some minerals, touch of yeast and lots of fresh, ripe
fruit. Fresh acidity, ripe tannins, raspberries, a bit hollow and some
popcorn. Good length. Easy going and very fruity. 87
1990 Chapoutier Châteauneuf-du-Pape Barbe Rac:
Ruby,
garnet rim. Extremelly scented, layered, red berries, some licorice and
raspberries. Some VA and ever so slightly oxidized. Dying off quickly
in the glass. Fresh acidity, tannins start to polish up, warm touch
(13,8) and lacks something. Not optimal bottle. (Bought directly at
Chapoutier this summer, so they need to check the wines in their storage. Bad cork has
let in air). 89
1990 Henri Bonneau Châteauneuf-du-Pape Cuvée Marie Beurrier:
Deep
ruby, garnet rim. Black- and blueberries, touch og VA, licorice, warm
feel. Fresh acidity, ripe and high of tannins, cherries and stone
from stone fruit, a bit dry after palate, and not too long. 90
1999 Schiavenza Barolo Riserva
Bright ruby, garnet rim. Tar, roses, licorice and cherries. Fresh acidity, ripe tannins, some strawberries, but a bit short. 88
1978 Scarpa Barbaresco Tettineive:
corked
1988 Giacomo Conterno Monfortino:
Faulty storage, cooked.
1999 Giacomo Conterno Monfortino:
Towards
bright ruby. Some tar, roses, somewhat scented, subdued and closed.
Licorice, sometimes intense, sometimes evasive. Hay. Ever so slightly
of glue. Fresh and high acidity, unripe apples and high tannins. Edgy
texture, elegant for Monfortino but hardly elegant compared to most
wines. Slightly warm finish. Long. Opened up a bit after two hours in the glass. 93
1988 Pio Cesare Barolo:
Deep
ruby, thin brick rim. Dusty, rose hips, tar, some licorice. Asphalt.
More scented with air. High acidity, a bit lean, high of ripe tannins,
chocolate and mature feel, getting into dusty teritory. Short. 87
1964 Fransesco Rinaldi Barolo:
Bright ruby, amber rim. Cooked plums, dried and dusty, some VA. Oxidized. Tired palate, dry.
2002 Château d'Issan:
Deep
ruby. Somewhat scented, cassis, leather, on the rich side. Fresh
acidity, ripe tannins, ever so slightly raw, some minerals, touch of
herbs, a bit boring. After two hours plus, floral and elegant cassis. 88
2002 Château Haut-Bailly:
Deep
ruby, garnet rim. Rich nose, blueberries, blackberries, ever so
slightly herbal and some minerals. Some alcohol. Fresh acidity, ripe
tannins, fresher palate, licorice, candy apples, rich for the vintage.
Not too complex, nailed producer but not vintage. After it had been open
for two hours, much more typical with minerals and more classic nose.
90
1983 Zilliken Saarburger Rauch Riesling Auslese:
Lemon
yellow. Medicinal, apples, wax and some honey. Fresh acidity, rounded,
refreshing, pure apples, lovely playfullness. Elegant, vibrant, apples
and ripe, sweet lemons. Long. 93
1983 Zilliken Saarburger Rauch Riesling Auslese:
Lemon
yellow. Medicinal, apples, wax and some honey. Fresh acidity, rounded,
refreshing, pure apples, lovely playfullness. Elegant, vibrant, apples
and ripe, sweet lemons. Long. 93
2003 Clos des Papes
Deep
ruby. Sweet, ungainly and alcoholic nose. Very sweet. Intense licorice.
Sweet, massive, alcoholic, all over the place, unbalanced. Terrible. 76
2005 Ramey Sonoma Coast Syrah:
Black
with purple rim. Rich, ungainly, ripe alcoholic and so sweet. Lazy
acidity, so ripe and alcoholic that you must be in a coma to taste it
again. Awful. 75
1999 Clos des Papes:
Deep ruby. Rich, sweet, licorice and blueberries floating in 60% proof. Some acidity, so sweet, unbalanced. 78
2003 Domaine du Pegau Châteauneuf-du-Pape:
Deep
ruby. Blueberries, blackberries and plums. Sweet. Has some acidity, so
sweet and again ungainly. Alcohol and sweetness all the way. 77
Katop Dionis Club (Moldovian sweet fortified red wine)
Katop Dionis Club (Moldovian sweet fortified red wine)
Deep ruby. Sweet licorice, alcohol and overripe fruit.
Alf falling in love with the Riesling
I usually follow your posts with interest especially on older wines.
ReplyDeleteHowever I was looking on the rating on Cellartracker for 2003 Pegau Cuvee Reservee you rated 77/100. 501 notes rate the wine at least above 90/100. I know the majority are not professionals. Nevertheless does it mean all of them don't know what they say ?
I like Pegau a lot.
I am very surprised that so many rates Pegau and also the Clos du Papes so high. For me its sweet and burning with alcohol, every proffesional should find them unbalanced, and the fruit is so sweet and overripe it feels more like soda than wine. If you taste it after fifty other wines and your palate is numb, I can maybe understand a high rating, but with a fresh palate, its impossible to have another glass, maybe even another sip, as it is for me. I cannot understand how people can drink these wines, or how they can rate them high.
ReplyDeleteOh, and thank you for following the blog.
ReplyDeleteI did not taste Pegau 2003, nor 1999 Clos des Papes but so far I found that Pegau manages to maintain a classic line, whatever that is for a Chateauneuf du pape. I tasted a line up of 2004, 2005, 2006 and 2007 Cuvee Reservee Pegau and by far I enjoyed the 2004 the most. 2004 as far as I understand being a cooler year in Chateauneuf.
ReplyDeleteI also know that when you taste a large number of wines one might misjudge some wines that, tasted alone, might be more appealing. But that's life.
You have, by far, access to some of the most interesting wines that are out there so the content of some of your posts have tremendous value. It would also help me if you could mention if there is any further aging potential left, especially for older wines. That I have not seen posted so far on your notes.
It would also be interesting to learn if any extensive aeration was necessarry to help having a better experience if one opens a similar bottle.
Keep it up !
Cosmin
Thank you for response. If I feel that a wine really needs cellar time, I normally write about it, and I have started with writing more about dekanting. But I agree, I could be better at it. Thanks for the comments.
ReplyDeleteChrister