The property at Château Pape Clément is more refined than it's wines, unfortunately.
2010 Château Bouscaut Blanc;Fresh, lively, smoky minerals, balanced, fresh and layered. 91-92
2010 Château Bouscaut Rouge;
Fresh, lively, just on the sweet and ripe side, minerals. 89-91
2010 Château Carbonnieux Blanc;
Elegant, refined, layered, beautiful texture, fresh acidity, lemons and long finish. 92-94
2010 Château Carbonnieux Rouge;
Elegant and feels more refined for red Carbonnieux, seems less excessively oaked, long. 91-93
2010 Domaine de Chevalier Blanc;
Layer upon layer, citrus, stunning acidity, balanced, incredible length, stunning. 94-96
2010 Domaine de Chevalier Rouge;
Perfumed and complex, fresh, lively, mouthwatering, stunning balance and freshness, long. Best DdC Rouge ever? 94-95
2010 Château Haut-Bailly;
Beautiful nose, fresh, lively, slightly hollow mid palate, yet again not convinced, disappointing considering vintage and appelation. 88-89
2010 Château Malartic Lagraviere Blanc;
Grapefruit and minerals, elegant, more fruit-driven style, superb length. 92-93
2010 Château Olivier Blanc;
Smokey Pessac minerals, citrus, stunning fruit and balance, very long. A new star is on it's way, especially on the whites. 93-95
2010 Château Pape Clément Blanc;
Bathing in oak, almost impossible to have any sensation of anything else. Overdone, massive and of little use. Impossible to drink. If Olivier is a rising star, this is not falling, it's plummeting. 83 if I'm kind.
2010 Château Smith Haut Lafitte Blanc;
Gorgeous nose, stunning flavor and texture, intense, great length. 93-94
2010 Château Smith Haut Lafitte Rouge;
Elegant, layered, refined, flirting and seductive, perfumed, long. 93-94