Four reds

2005 Penfolds RWT, Barossa Shiraz;
Deep ruby, ruby rim. Some barrique, mint, lots of sweet morellos, pepper, vanilla and violets, a bit perfumed. Good acidity, some liquorice, overripe raspberries, some alcohol touch, needs time. 83

2001 Chateau Marquis de Terme;
Ruby, green bell peppers, cassies, green beans, blackcurrants, leather, stable and herbs. Great balance and fresh acidity, ripe tannins, a bit lean body, but elegant, great finish. 87

2004 Bodegas Alion;
Deep ruby, ruby rim. Lots of liquorice, red berries, coffee, some vanilla and dark chocolate. Very young. Fresh acidity, fruit driven for the moment, quite a few tannins, great balance and texture, keep. 89

2001 Gaja Sperss;
Bright ruby, tar and roses, some liquorice, cherries, morellos, red berries, very elegant and complex, very young still. Great acidity, ripe tannins, great balance, very intence, long finish. Drinks beautifully now, but will improve. 93